The Leaders' Debate
Wed, 29 Oct 2003
A more-or-less faithful transcription of the televised leaders'
debate from the 2003 Saskatchewan provincial election
The cast:
Premier Lorne Calvert, New Democratic Party leader, former United Church minister, still inclined to sermonise
Elwin Hermanson, Saskatchewan Party leader, farmer, free enterprise advocate, cursed with potato-shaped head
David Karwacki, Liberal Party leader, personal friend of Paul Martin, terminal lightweight
Exchange #1: Privatising Crown Corporations
CALVERT: If he is elected, Mr. Hermanson intends to privatise the Crown
Corporations!
HERMANSON: Nuh-uh!
CALVERT: Uh-huh!
HERMANSON: Nuh-uh! You're the one who wants to privatise the Crown Corporations...and
I have the secret cabinet documents to prove it!
CALVERT: Hah! Those "secret cabinet documents" aren't a secret at all!
Everyone knows we tried to privatise the Crown Corporations!
HERMANSON: So you admit you want to privatise the Crown Corporations,
just like I do!
CALVERT: No, I don't.
HERMANSON: Neither do I!
Exchange #2: David Karwacki, Serious Leader
PANELIST: Mr. Karwacki, you're, like, nineteen years old. Why should
the people of Saskatchewan take you seriously as a political leader?
KARWACKI: Unlike the other leaders, I bring real-world business experience
to the table.
HERMANSON: Hah.
KARWACKI: My successful fruit-shipping company has successfully shipped
fruit all over the continent.
HERMANSON: Get over yourself, Doogie.
KARWACKI: Moreover, I am close personal friends with all our leaders
in Ottawa, including Ralph, Lyle, and of course Paul.
CALVERT (interrupting): But will you stand up to your friends
in Ottawa when we need to extort more money from them to support our greedy
farmers?
KARWACKI: Yes! I hate my friends in Ottawa! Especially my good friend
Paul, with whom I am on a first-name basis. Paul, Paul, Paul.
HERMANSON: Hah! What have you ever done for the greedy farmers of Saskatchewan?
KARWACKI: As you may recall, I personally organised a meeting between
my good friends Ralph and Lyle and Premier Calvert to raise funds for our
greedy farmers. And then I wasn't even invited to the meeting! Which was,
like, totally unfair.
CALVERT: Quit whining, Richie Rich. Maybe if you actually got elected
to something we'd let you come to the meetings.
KARWACKI: Shut up! I'm gonna tell Paul you said that.
Exchange #3: Tax Cuts
CALVERT: Mr. Hermanson, the tax cuts you're proposing are simply unsustainable.
HERMANSON: No, they're not.
CALVERT: Yes, they are.
HERMANSON: Nuh-uh, they're not, and you know who agrees with me? Your party's
own Finance Minister!
CALVERT: Everyone knows our Finance Minister is completely unreliable!
KARWACKI (interrupting): Mr. Hermanson, your whole platform is
based on nothing but tax cuts!
HERMANSON: That's not true. We also want to put our young people in
boot camp.
KARWACKI: Putting our young people in boot camp will turn them into
thugs!
HERMANSON: By giving our thugs tax breaks we'll turn them into respectable
citizens.
KARWACKI: Now, when I'm premier, I'll cut your taxes by...
HERMANSON: Now, hold on. You just said you were against tax cuts!
KARWACKI: I'm not opposed to tax cuts, only the divisive tax
cuts offered by your party.
HERMANSON: Watch your mouth or I'll put you in boot camp!
Exchange #4: Negativity
PANELIST: Mr. Calvert, how do you feel about the negative nature of
this campaign?
CALVERT: First off, I've already apologised for all my name-calling
and accusations. Secondly, he's the one being negative, not me!
HERMANSON: Your negativity disgusts me, you hypocrite!
KARWACKI: Look at all this fearmongering and divisiveness. It just makes
me sad. Luckily, I'm above it all.
CALVERT: Be quiet, Junior. If there's anyone mongering fear, it's Mr.
Hermanson - by trying to sell the Crown Corporations!
HERMANSON: I already said I'm not trying to sell the Crown Corporations!
CALVERT: And then he makes it worse by lying about it!
HERMANSON: No, you're lying!
CALVERT: No, you are!
HERMANSON: Nuh-uh!
CALVERT: Uh-huh!
KARWACKI: It's just so terribly sad. So sad I can hardly bear it. What
a terrible shame. Sigh.
The Closing Statements:
CALVERT: Mr. Hermanson has a secret plan to privatise the Crown Corporations,
and his tax cuts are unsustainable.
HERMANSON: I will never, ever, ever, ever privatise the Crown Corporations,
and it's time for a change.
KARWACKI: I have a beautiful wife and four angelic children, and we...
CALVERT (interrupting): I have a son too. He's in a rock band.
HERMANSON: I have a secret plan to put Mr. Calvert's son in boot camp!
KARWACKI: Be quiet, both of you! This is my closing statement!
HERMANSON: Go tell it to the Prime Minister, Doogie.
Known knowns.
Monday, December 01, 2003
LONDON, England (Reuters) -- A comment last year by Defense
Secretary Donald Rumsfeld on the hunt for Iraq's weapons of mass destruction
was awarded the "Foot in Mouth" prize Monday by Britain's Plain English
Campaign.
Rumsfeld, renowned for his uncompromising tough talking, received
the prize for the most baffling comment by a public figure.
"Reports that say something hasn't happened are always interesting
to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we
know we know," Rumsfeld told a news briefing.
"We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there
are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns --
the ones we don't know we don't know."
John Lister, spokesman for the campaign, which strives to have public
information delivered in clear, straightforward English, said: "We think
we know what he means. But we don't know if we really know."
Sigh. It appears that the "Plain English Campaign" has been hijacked by
ideologues. Rumsfeld's comments are perfectly lucid. Look at them again:
"There are known knowns - there are things we know we know;
"We also know there are known unknowns - that is to say, we know there
are some things we do not know.
"But there are also unknown unknowns -- the ones we don't know we don't
know."
It's not exactly Descartes, but it's a fairly eloquent dissertation
on the limits of human knowledge - and all in words of two syllables or
less. The fact that his administration turned out to be wrong about what
they knew and what they didn't know only underlines Rumsfeld's perspicacity.
When the spokesman says "We think we know what he means. But we don't
know if we really know," either he's an idiot, or what he really means
is, "Where are your weapons of mass destruction now, Rambo?" Sad when you
have to decipher the press releases of the Plain English Campaign.